2 comments on “Songs from the Pakistani Choo Mantar, Starring Noor Jehan

  1. Hi Richard. Just a small correction and that is there are 5 more songs in the film. I just uploaded the Noor Jehan ones because she’s so much better than Zubaida Khanum, as you noted. The male singer, Zarif, has some too. The ones I can’t get enough of are the boat song, Hasde Nachde Gande Thande Thande Panio, and her first song on stage, Neeli Chaat Waliya. Here you’ve been singing the praises of Noor Jehan for years and only now am I finally listening to her and agreeing. Silly me. :)

  2. Hi, Tom. OK, thanks, I will rephrase that soon. And, I am so glad that you have seen the light regarding Noor Jehan! :) Regarding the Noor Jehan songs in Choo Mantar, it is difficult for me to say which are my favorites, because I like them all so much! The boat song is probably the first clip that caught my attention, and “Aeni Gal Gas Diyo” (her second song on stage?) became a listening standard apart from the film. But each time I’ve heard/seen a new one, I have pretty much liked it just as much.

    Zubaida Khanum isn’t on the same level, but she”s done a lot of good playback singing, and she sang a surprisingly good number of songs for ’40s-era Hindi film actresses who moved to Pakistan after partition. I am writing this comment a few hours after I put up a new Zubaida Khanum favorites post. I hope people will like some of those songs also, as I do, very much.

    I think Zubaida did really well in a kind of number that was far from the semi-classical Indian mode – i.e., those jazzy pop/cabaret songs with a Latin beat. There are a few of those in my next post…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s